Critical thinking is the differentiator when AI makes everything

AI gives everyone the same skills, to some degree. Imran on why marketing backfires when the thinking is handed to AI, and why the strongest work says very little.

Imran Ahmed

AF

Imran Ahmed

Head of Delivery

·

October 20, 2026

·

5 min read

Critical thinking is the differentiator when AI makes everything
The short version

Use AI to create. Use experience to decide what to keep.

  • When the strategy is handed to AI, campaigns go out without anyone thinking through the repercussions.
  • Trying to work as fast as AI is when mistakes happen.
  • Curate what AI gives you rather than publishing all of it.
  • Design and development need the same critical eye: fewer AI traits, fewer frameworks.
  • In-house teams need experts who have seen their industry change.

Critical thinking is the differentiator in the world of AI. AI gives us all the same skills, to some degree, depending on what industry you look at.

Marketing backfires when the thinking is handed to AI

There are lots of examples where marketing can backfire, and you have to be careful. A lot of people use AI to scale whatever they're putting out: marketing messaging, adverts, campaigns.

They're not really thinking about the repercussions of those campaigns, because it's not their original idea. They think: that sounds like a good idea, let's put it out to the market.

The process of coming up with the marketing strategy is almost being outsourced to AI, and that's where we're seeing a lot more things backfire. People aren't brainstorming as much. They're not getting together to come up with a good idea and think through all the different angles.

Speed is where the mistakes creep in

AI has created an indirect pressure, because it's made things so fast. When you do things manually, you almost want to compete with AI and do it as fast as AI. That's when we start making mistakes, and marketing backfires.

Curate what AI gives you, don't publish all of it

What I'm seeing a lot of now is campaigns, landing pages and websites with a lot of copy, because AI has generated everything.

Critical thinking is using your industry experience to say: let's cut away all this fluff and noise. It's making very precise decisions about what we're going to keep, not publishing everything AI gives you. It's curating it.

Definitely use AI to help you create content. But you see it all over the place now: reams and reams of text. That's where critical thinking comes in.

Design and development need the same critical eye

Design is another example. AI tools can do great designs, but what's the thinking behind every decision? There are little eyebrows everywhere, which is a common AI trait, plus little icons and text. Is it all necessary?

It needs a critical designer's eye to say: let's remove all this. It needs a critical developer's eye to say we shouldn't be using this many frameworks, when it could all be done with some basic JavaScript.

It takes critical thinkers with expertise in their domain to remove all this noise. That's where we're going to start to see brands standing out more.

In-house teams need experience, not just tools

Marketing teams, design teams and development teams, especially in-house ones, need expertise. But they also need someone who's not just good at what they do, but has seen various iterations of that industry.

Design has changed so much. The tools have changed, and development stacks have changed so many times. PPC is always changing: now you've got paid campaigns inside AI tools as well.

It's those years of experience that help you differentiate yourself from everyone else just using AI to put out a campaign or create a landing page. Experts bring that experience because they understand human psychology. I don't think AI is quite there yet, though it's getting really good.

Those experts can save a lot of time and money on campaigns that are otherwise pretty much guesswork, because AI just says: this is what you should be doing. Having experts in-house is the key differentiator.

From the specialist

The most impactful marketing website campaigns are the ones that say very little but get the message across.

Imran Ahmed

AF

Imran Ahmed

Head of Delivery

·

Ascensor

Questions

Questions this piece answers.

Want a view on your own business? Tell us what you are trying to achieve and we will tell you how we would approach it.

Talk to us

→

Why does critical thinking matter when using AI?

+

AI gives everyone roughly the same skills, so the difference comes from the people using it. Critical thinking means using industry experience to cut the fluff and decide precisely what to keep, rather than publishing everything AI produces.

Why does AI-generated marketing backfire?

+

When the strategy is handed to AI, people stop brainstorming and thinking through the angles, so they miss the repercussions. The speed AI creates also puts pressure on teams to rush, which is when mistakes creep in.

How do you stop AI-generated design looking generic?

+

Question every element. AI designs often add eyebrows, icons and text that aren't needed. A critical designer removes the noise, and a critical developer avoids stacking frameworks where basic JavaScript would do.

In practice

Case studies where this was the work.

Case studies where this was the work. Each card shows the headline result.

All case studies →
Get in touch

Want a specialist's view on your business?

A few details is enough to start. We will reply to say how we would approach it.

Prefer to call? 0113 831 4400

By clicking send below, you consent to allow Ascensor to store and process the personal information submitted above to reply to your enquiry. See our privacy policy.

✓

Thanks, we have your enquiry.

One of our specialists will reply to say how we would approach it. Want to talk sooner? Call 0113 831 4400.

Sorry, something went wrong sending that. Please try again, or call us on 0113 831 4400.
Keep reading

More insights.

Related services
More insights